Double-Dip Recession: It Can’t Happen…But It’s Happening

by:Dave Lindorff

It was just as recently as a year ago that the authorities in politics, business and academe were stating boldly and confidently that the nation’s economy was on the mend, and that there was no chance of a backslide into recession again.

Take Lakshman Achuthan and Anirvan Banerji who are, respectively, co-founder and chief operating officer and co-founder and chief research officer of ECRI, the Economic Cycle Research Institute.

“The good news is that the much-feared double-dip recession is not going to happen,” they said on CNN on Oct. 28, last year. “After completing an exhaustive review of key drivers of the business cycle, ranging from credit to inventories and measures of labor market conditions, we can forecast with confidence that the economy will avoid a double dip.”

“We will not have a double-dip recession at all,” said Warren Buffett, the multi-billionaire investor called, by his fans, the Oracle of Omaha, back on September 13, 2010. “I see business coming back almost across the board,” he told an assembled group of bankers.

And of course, there was Ben Bernanke, the chairman of the Federal Reserve, who actually acts on his presumed wisdom, saying, on June 8, 2010, “”There seems to be a good bit of momentum in consumer spending and investment,” he said at the time. “My best guess is we’ll have a continued recovery [but] it won’t feel terrific.”

Even a Vistage Survey of CEOs, conducted release last Oct. 4, showed the confidence index respondents, all top executives at public companies, saying there was “no evidence” for a double dip back into recession in the nation’s economic future.

So much for expert opinion.

This week we have seen new unemployment claims top 400,000 for the eighth week in a row. Manufacturing has fallen to where it was in 2009, the respected Case-Shiller Housing Index has declared that the housing price collapse has gone into a second dip, with home prices nationwide now back down to where they were in 1999 and still falling, and consumer confidence, according to the Conference Board, is down to 60.8 (in 1988 it was 100), a serious slump in a nation where 72 percent of the economy consists normally of consumer spending.

Okay, we’re not in a second round of recession yet, but with economic “growth” slumping into to 1.8 percent for the first quarter of this year, and nothing up ahead to suggest it will get better, there’s every reason to think we could move into negative territory before long.

Also, this stuff about recession is a bit nebulous anyhow. A recession is defined as two back-to-back quarters of negative growth, but when you go from 3% growth — the bare minimum in theory to have jobs being created at a rate sufficient to employ all the new workers entering the job market — to 1% or 2%, it might as well be called a recession. Some companies may still be making profits by operating at a lower than capacity level, but unemployment will be rising, people will be getting poorer, more homes will be going into foreclosure, schools will be laying off teachers, and the general level of misery in the nation will be rising.

Incumbent politicians might try to call that a “recovery,” but that’s really stretching the English language.

So how did all these supposedly smart people get things so wrong?

Any fool can see the problem. The Americans who own their own homes have seen what they thought was their major asset shrink in value by at least a third. Don’t even talk about what meager savings they might have had. Back in July 2008, before the markets crashed, Americans had a total indebtedness of $2.5 trillion. The average American was reportedly saving less than $400 per year. We were living on credit, not saving. Those who did have some money saved and who had been investing it saw it lose 43% of its value almost overnight.

Sure, some of those people, who left their money sitting in the same equities they had been in before the crash got most of it back this year, but an awful lot of those people cashed out at the bottom, not wanting to risk losing any more. Their loses are permanent. Others cashed out because they lost their jobs and needed the money. Their losses are permanent.

This is what the too-smart economists, politicians and CEOs simply don’t get. In their world–the one that just looks at P&L statements, shares words of “wisdom” over golf tees, and profits from illegal but routine insider tips on investment opportunities the rest of us don’t learn about–things look pretty good. Companies are profitable, having laid off huge swaths of workers, bashed unions, won pay and benefit “give-backs” from employees and tax breaks from politicians, elected officials have been re-elected, thanks to friendly backing from the corporate media, and plenty of lucre from corporate PACs, and the tax breaks for the rich that were enacted under the prior Bush/Cheney administration have been extended by the Obama administration, so the well-heeled don’t even have to pay much in taxes.

In our world, though, there are higher taxes, higher gas prices, higher food prices, increased bank charges, miniscule interest or no interest at all on any savings, higher tuition and less in financial aid for our kids, no jobs, pay cuts, and if we’re laid off, there’s no more health care.

So where do the happy-talk forecasters of “recovery” get the idea that we ordinary Americans are going to get out there and spend? Where do they get the idea that the great consumer “engine” that powered the economy for the last three or four decades is going to rev up again?

These idiots should go walk around a few shopping malls. What a dismal experience that is!

They should go stand in an unemployment office application line and talk to a few of the newly laid-off. Of better yet, volunteer at a food bank and talk to the people coming in for food assistance (at least that way these parasites would be doing something useful while they did their research).

If they did a little of that real research, they might not be so quick to make jackasses of themselves again, predicting confidently that there’s no double-dip recession in the cards for the US economy.

I’m not holding my breath, but whether they take my advice or not, I’m ready to offer them a challenge: let’s check back this time next year, and see who was right, them or me.

5 Responses

  1. my bet is with you. I don’t know where it is all leading, but it doesn’t seem sustainable.

  2. well, well, well, so what to do about it? Praying 15 years everybody to jump out of the wheel created you still go and seek for a personal survival and the acceptance of the unavoidable? Tired of all this crap and waiting it to implode within short due…. yours LSL

  3. The main stream circus news media is controlled by the illuminati Masonic Zionist Bankers. There Luciferian Philosophy is; we shall wage war by means of deception. The end justifies the means. Might is right! In the begginings of the structure of society, they were subject to brutal and blind force, afterwards to law which is the same force only disguised. I draw the conclusion by the law of nature right lies in force. The word means no more than give me what I want in order that I may prove I am stronger than you. A new right emerges that of the strong. The political has nothing to do with the moral. A ruler is governed by the moral is not a skillful political politicians, therefore ustable upon his thrown. He must have recourse both to cunning and make believe or fraud. The word shall not agree with the deeds of the diplomat. Per me regas regnant. Through me kings rein. There countersign is force and make believe or fraud. Greed breeds corruptions and fraud. He that has the biggest stick makes the rules. He that owns the gold makes the rule. The news media, politiicns and the chairman of the central bank keep telling the people that the economy is improving. Prosperity is just around the cornner. What they really mean is, to keep spending your money. If they tell the people the truth, it will cause a panic, and it is bad for business. This all part of the fleecing of the flock before they are lead to the slaughter. There agenda is to break the middle class. They are going to run the middle class through the washing machine ringer, and than they are going to pull the plug on the sink drain. The elite politicians, bankers, and industrialist will emerge as rulers and we the people will be surfs and bond slaves to corporate feudalism. When we appointed the necessary person into the international sphere of finance, they began to pay us tribute of subjects and all the monies of the world began to flow into our cash boxes. Only if themasses should wake-up and turn on their oppresors. The only way to conquer the dark forces is to expose their fraud with the truth and for the masses to unite and form a grass roots movement. There is safety in numbers. The following are the implements of change. 1-National strikes 2-Boycotts 3-flyers 4-Picketing 5-Peaceful Demonstrations 6-Underground Cash and Barter Economy. It may take acts of civil disobedience to change the system. Without discipline and sacrafice nothing will change. Freedom is not free!

    • James you are right but no one willing to do the necessary jump in the head. People dont like to remember that we organized once on non-money based economies and trade. They are still buying blood gold and do not think that there is no can of lentils to be bought with and got shot on top of it.
      I went self sustainable with my folks in nature rich anden mountains of colombia. This is something everybody can do, if needing assistance:

  4. GJS says:

    An excellent assessment, in my 50 odd years I have never seen such a scenario that has the potential to actually collapse the world economy, paper money is indeed worthless, it is a promisery note from a group of Politicians & Bankers, we must all should know by now just how little that means & act accordingly.
    It truly is time for people to realise this has NEVER been a cyclic downturn nor will it end like one.
    Good luck all.

Leave a Reply

© 2011 Pakalert Press. All rights reserved.